Creole Cream Cheese Info

A Recipe for Making Creole Cream Cheese

Before I began my research, this was not a cheese that I knew much about. In fact it wasn't even on my radar until we began getting a number of our customers asking how to make it.

Once I began my research, what I found was a very beautiful piece of regional cheese history and the story of several people bringing this cheese back to life. I really love the history behind these traditional cheese making processes, as well as the people that make them.

My development of the recipe began by gleaning several recipes from others, like chefs Emeril Lagasse, and John Folce from Bittersweet Dairy. I have made a few changes to this and I hope it will meet the approval of those that remember this cheese, as well as those making it again.

In the spring when I created this recipe, 'Old Man' had finally relaxed his grip on the North East and so I was ready to celebrate by making this wonderful cheese. This is a cheese that had disappeared but is back again. A real piece of cheese history from the Creole Country of Louisiana.

What is Creole Cream Cheese

Creole Cream Cheese is a farmer style cheese similar to a combination of cottage cheese and sour cream. Today, Creole cream cheese is again being made by a few dairies in the region.

The cheese is made with a blend of skim milk and half & half cream. Once the curd is made and drained, a little heavy cream is poured over it. Adding fat to lean makes sense to me, considering that 'Mardi Gras' does mean 'Fat Tuesday' after all!

One of my favorite ways to eat it is, spooned into a bowl, covered with either half-and-half or whipping cream, and served with fresh fruit. Yum!

A Bit of History

This style of cheese was thought to have been brought to Louisiana from the Brittany and Burgundy regions of France, and was extremely popular in the area in the 1800s through the 1980s when production ceased.

Although originally a product of France, many New Orleans dairies, such as Goldseal and Borden, supplied the city with the product for many years.

Acadians called this 'Caille Goute', or Creamed Clabber (clabber being a naturally fermented milk), and it was often made by the family at home as well.

Here is an excerpt taken from a 1901 copy of 'The Picayune's Creole Cook Book'
The ‘Cream Cheese Woman’ is still as common a sight on our New Orleans streets as the Cala Woman was in the days gone by. She carries a covered basket in which are a number of small perforated tins in which the Cheeses are. In her other hand she carries a can of fresh Cream. She sells her wares to her regular customers, for the old Creoles who do not make their own Cream Cheese are very particular as to whom they buy from, and when once a good careful, clean woman gets a ‘customer’ she keeps her during her period of business, coming every fast day and Friday with her Cheese and Cream, for this is a great fast-day breakfast and luncheon dish.

The cheese was made by several small dairies in the New Orleans area for many years, but began to disappear as these family dairies were absorbed into larger production dairies or just plain went out of business.

By the 1980's Creole cream cheese was well on its way to extinction due to:

  1. raw milk sales no longer allowed
  2. commercial cream cheese such as Philadelphia brand became available
  3. diet trending to avoidance of high fats

A Good Cheese Returns

Since the late 1990's, Creole cream cheese has undergone a quiet revival due to the work of food preservationist Poppy Tooker and fans who grew up on it.

During the early 2000's the inclusion of Creole Cream Cheese into Slow Foods Ark of Taste brought back a revival of this cheese.

One of the larger producers today is the Mauthe Family Dairy. Over time, Kenny and Jamie Mauthe transitioned from milking 150 cows and selling all their milk to a gigantic co-op, to milking just a couple dozen cows, processing the milk themselves and selling it to customers directly at farmers’ markets. When they downsized, around 2000, the Mauthes also resurrected the old Louisiana dairy farming tradition of producing Creole cream cheese. While there was one other small producer in the area at the time, many locals credit the Mauthe's product with saving Creole cream cheese from extinction.

Traditionally this cheese was eaten right out of the container with a bit of sugar sprinkled on top, but there are all kinds of ways to eat this delicious product:

  1. Put fresh fruit on it
  2. Use it to cook with it (it’s great in pasta)
  3. Make cheesecakes with it

We have been told that the Mauthe's version tastes like a cross between ricotta and creme fraiche with a hint of buttermilk.

Using Raw Clabbered Milk

Traditionally, raw milk was used to make this cheese, no culture or rennet added, and the cheese drained in cloth bags before being placed in molds.

According to 'The Picayune's Creole Cook Book' written in 1901
"Cream cheese is always made from clabbered milk [this would be a raw milk with its own natural culture that clabbered or fermented on it's own with no culture or rennet addition]
Many of the Creoles, however, make their own cream cheese as follows: The clabber is placed in a long bag of muslin and put to drain, the bag being tied tightly and hung out over night in a cool place [Sometimes outdoors hanging from a tree limb]. When ready for use, the bag is opened and the cheese is taken out and beaten till light. It is the placed in these perforated molds, and when time comes for serving, it is taken out, placed in a dish, and sweet cream poured over it. It is eaten with sugar or salt, more generally sugar."

You can try this with the full fat milk or even raw milk as well. I have read that the milk of choice was the richer milk from Guernsey or Jersey cows. The natural clabber should only be attempted with a very high confidence in your raw milk quality, so be careful. The natural clabber should NEVER be attempted with pasteurized milk.

The 'no-rennet' will work as a full lactic coagulation but may take longer and the cream will rise during the set.

Frozen Cream Cheese Dessert

As a final note, I received this page from Alyce in Alabama.

She pointed out that Ricki had published a newsletter years ago (Part of her rep as the 'Cheese Queen'). Even 17 years ago when Ricki published this, the references were from a time long before that. Check out that yummy Frozen Cream Cheese recipe from 1940 and enjoy.