Yogurt and Butter

Yogurt and butter are easy to make and more economical than comparable store bought alternatives. With only two ingredients, milk and culture, homemade probiotic rich, high protein yogurt helps you step away from commercial additives. From sweet to tangy, make it just the way you like.

23 products

Save 20%

Yogurt Making Kit for plain and Greek yogurt, includes essentials for making five 2-quart batches at home.

Yogurt Making Kit4.9

$19.95

$15.96

Save 20%

4.9

Save 20%

Yogurt Starter Culture Sample Pack4.9

$19.90

$15.92

Save 20%

4.9

Save 15%

Sweet yogurt starter culture with bowl of yogurt topped with berries, perfect for making homemade yogurt.

Yogurt Starter Culture (Sweet)4.9

$9.95

$8.46

Save 15%

4.9

Save 15%

Creamy yogurt starter culture featuring a bowl of yogurt topped with berries, promotes homemade yogurt making.

Yogurt Starter Culture (Creamy)4.9

$9.95

$8.46

Save 15%

4.9

Save 20%

Making Cheese Butter & Yogurt kit with recipe book and five starter cultures for homemade cheese.

Making Cheese, Butter & Yogurt Kit (B70, C20, C33, C101, C201, Y5)4.9

$55.70

$44.56

Save 20%

4.9

Save 20%

Beginner Cheese and Yogurt Making Kit Bundle with cheese and yogurt kits for homemade dairy delights.

Beginner Cheese and Yogurt Making Bundle

$47.90

$38.32

Save 20%

DIY Mozzarella and Yogurt Making Kits for fresh homemade dairy, perfect for beginners and food enthusiasts.

DIY Mozzarella & Yogurt Making Bundle

$47.90

$38.32

Save 20%

On sale

Biena Yogurt Type I Starter Culture packet for making yogurt and Greek yogurt.

Yogurt Type I Starter Culture4.9

$19.95

From $16.96

On sale

4.9

Sold out

Biena Yogurt Yo-Dolce starter culture packet for homemade yogurt and fermented milks.

Yogurt Yo-Dolce Starter Culture4.5

$19.95

$16.96

4.5

Save 15%

Buttermilk starter culture package by New England Cheese Making for making thick, healthy buttermilk. Enough to make up to five, two quart batches

Buttermilk Starter Culture5.0

$9.95

$8.46

Save 15%

5.0

On sale

Tel - Tru Thermometer - New England Cheesemaking Supply Company

Tel-Tru Thermometer4.7

$29.95

From $25.46

On sale

4.7

On sale

Homesteading Creamery Kitchen Essentials - New England Cheesemaking Supply Company

Butter Muslin5.0

$5.95

From $5.06

On sale

5.0

Save 15%

Yogotherm Yogurt Maker - New England Cheesemaking Supply Company

Yogotherm Yogurt Maker4.9

$44.95

$38.21

Save 15%

4.9

Sold out

a photo of a juicer with a bottle next to it

Yogurt and Greek Yogurt Maker4.9

$69.95

$59.46

4.9

Sold out

2 Quart Glass Yogurt Jar5.0

$22.95

$19.51

5.0

Save 15%

Automatic Yogurt Maker - New England Cheesemaking Supply Company

Automatic Yogurt Maker4.5

$59.95

$50.96

Save 15%

4.5

Save 15%

Extra Glass Jars For Automatic Yogurt Maker - New England Cheesemaking Supply Company

Extra Glass Jars For Automatic Yogurt Maker4.0

$29.95

$25.46

Save 15%

4.0

Save 15%

Greek Yogurt Strainer - New England Cheesemaking Supply Company

Greek Yogurt Strainer4.8

$39.95

$33.96

Save 15%

4.8

Save 15%

Yogurt Cheese Strainer - New England Cheesemaking Supply Company

Yogurt Cheese Strainer4.5

$25.95

$22.06

Save 15%

4.5

Save 15%

Butter Churn - New England Cheesemaking Supply Company

Butter Churn4.6

$54.95

$46.71

Save 15%

4.6

Save 15%

Butter Paddle Set - New England Cheesemaking Supply Company

Butter Paddle Set4.8

$15.95

$13.56

Save 15%

4.8

Save 15%

Homemade Yogurt & Kefir

$19.95

$16.96

Save 15%

Making Cheese, Butter & Yogurt - New England Cheesemaking Supply Company

Making Cheese, Butter & Yogurt4.9

$5.95

$5.06

Save 15%

4.9

Cheese Making Recipes

Make Your Favorite Cheese

From The Blog

Tips and Tricks

Beginner

Boost Your Gut Health with Homemade Yogurt

Beginner

How to Make Cheese at Home: Beginner’s Guide

Cheese Travels

Parmesan vs. Romano: Differences, Recipes and Cheese Making Tips

Over 10k 5-star reviews 365 Day guarantee Community of cheese makers Family owned and operated Helping cheese makers since 1978 100+ Free recipes 365 Day guarantee Cheese making made easy